In the past week and a half Pfizer and Moderna have announced their COVID vaccines have proven 95% effective. “It’s just as good as it gets — 94.5% is truly outstanding,” Fauci told CNN.
According to Biopharma Dive, “no vaccine has ever been developed so quickly, never mind manufactured for the world. The goal, at least in the U.S., is to have a vaccine ready for use in some fashion by the end of the year, or early next.”
Although doctors suggest the vaccine may not be readily available for the general public for several months, business owners are already turning to their Human Resources professionals, such as Flex HR, Inc., wondering whether or not they should require their employees to be vaccinated. And if that is legal?
Can Employers Mandate Vaccines?
In short, the answer is yes. The U.S. Occupational Safety and Health Administration (“OSHA”) claims employers can require their staff to get influenza vaccines, for example, but emphasizes that employees “need to be properly informed of the benefits of vaccinations.” Obligatory workplace vaccinations are not a new concept despite the focus of our national conscience. For years employers have included mandatory vaccination programs into their policies and procedures within the company Handbook.
In fact, flu vaccine guidelines have been a part of specific industry policies for a very long time; particularly for healthcare workers. Amy Traub, an attorney with BakerHostetler in New York City, told the Society for Human Resource Management that hospitals and nursing homes, in particular, have a compelling argument for requiring the COVID-19 vaccine given that their employees interact largely with immunocompromised patients.
According to JacksonLewis, “Neither the EEOC nor OSHA has published guidance (yet) on the issue of COVID-19 vaccines in the workplace; however, currently, both the EEOC and OSHA recommend encouraging, not necessarily requiring, flu vaccines.”
What If An Employee Refuses?
It’s inevitable that some workers are going to reject getting the vaccine. Pushback could be for political or religious reasons, medical concerns, or even out of fear. OSHA goes on to explain that “an employee who refuses vaccination because of a reasonable belief that he or she has a medical condition that creates a real danger of serious illness or death (such as a serious reaction to the vaccine) may be protected under Section 11(c) of the Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970 pertaining to whistleblower rights.” Flex HR, an industry-leading full-service HR firm supporting all HR functions, recommends employers take the time to listen to their employees’ concerns. If an individual opposes receiving the coronavirus shot, allow them to provide an explanation for their refusal of the vaccine. This could include justification of their religious beliefs or a note provided by their medical advisor addressing their medical condition and other health risks.
The Civil Rights Act also compels employers to issue a reasonable protective alternative — such as wearing a mask or allowing employees to work remotely (if possible) — in lieu of a vaccine. However, a worker who objected to a vaccine requirement “for moral or political reasons would not be protected,” CNN Business reported. If an employer puts a COVID vaccination mandate into the company policy as a term and condition of employment and an employee refuses to comply, he or she may even be fired if no accommodation can be made.
Considerations
Before an employer goes to their HR department requesting to add a vaccination policy for their staff, consider these premeditations below when weighing this very controversial decision.
-
- Is mandating a vaccine policy really necessary or are there other measures your workplace can take first?
- Have you required your staff to wear masks in the office, created more physical distance between working spaces, or allowed employees to work from home in order to prevent the spread of COVID-19?
- Encourage employees to get all vaccinations and be sure their vaccinations are up to date to keep themselves and their co-workers safe.
- Employers that decide to put a vaccination policy in place should seek HR expertise in adapting this new requirement.
- Offer flu shots and other vaccinations at no cost to the workforce and even make an on-site location for staff to get during working hours.
Requiring the workforce to receive the COVID-19 vaccine is a tough choice for one’s business. The pandemic has undoubtedly triggered employers to adapt to an unknowing, changing environment. Jim Cichanski, Flex HR’s CEO notes “I know we will receive more direction as we get closer to the arrival of a COVID-19 vaccine. In the past, guidance from OHSA has been to protect your workers and the workplace by allowing employers to demand COVID negative tests before returning to the office. One good piece of advice is to require employees to get tested for COVID. This protocol aligns with providing that safe haven working environment for all staff. Now we await potentially the same type of guidance once the actual vaccine is released.”
When Do Employers Have To Decide?
Employers have quite a few months to make the decision whether or not they will mandate their staff to get the new Coronavirus vaccine. The CDC indicates that the 21 million healthcare workers will be the priority, then followed closely by first responders, teachers, high risk, and over 65 years old. Dr. Moncef Slaoui, chief science adviser for the federal government’s Operation Warp Speed says, “each state will independently decide, taking account the guidance, who to immunize.” He goes on to say “20 million Americans could be vaccinated by next month.” As employers continue to explore all their policy options, they should remain vigilantly prepared, proceed with caution, and obtain expert HR support sooner rather than later.
Engaging business complexities is perplexing enough without the added burden of doing so during a pandemic. Dr. John Cascone, SVP at Flex HR, has commented “many CEOs are reaching out for guidance in an effort to provide sound direction to their management team and employees to keep them safe and productive during this critical period.” Leadership is continually challenged with making effective and balanced decisions for both staff and the organization. Simultaneously all while trying to enforce the company’s core values and safeguarding the well-being of employees. To ease the burden of management, Flex HR experts have created “helpful tips for managing the Coronavirus crisis” online, specifically addressing COVID-19 business impact concerns. For checklists, sample return to work letters, and other essential information for having your staff return to work, contact Flex HR now.
Thank you for visiting our blog.
Jim Weber – Managing Partner, ITB Partners
I hope you enjoyed our point of view and would like to receive regular posts directly to your email inbox. Toward this end, put your contact information on my mailing list.
Your feedback helps me continue to publish articles that you want to read. Your input is very important to me so; please leave a comment.
Convergence occurred when I remembered a conversation the prior week with another consultant, Faith. She had told me about an adverse situation created when a patient received a new heart, but the system hadn’t been updated to reflect the candidate’s eligibility for a transplant. That breakdown in the process created a question as to who’s responsible for the $1.4 million approximate costs of the procedure. Faith explained that this glitch was an administrative error as the candidate still needed the heart and was qualified to receive the transplant, however, an updated authorization wasn’t secured. I can only imagine how bad the situation could have been if the patient had died, prevented from receiving the transplant due to an administrative mistake. It occurred to me that the system has a fundamental flaw that can be mitigated with a technical solution. Faith continued by providing an overview of additional risk and complexity created by Federal Agencies and Laws regulating the Health Care Industry.
While engaged in recent networking activities I became acquainted with a Senior Consultant assigned to the Atlanta office for a National Outplacement Company. He had heard about ITB Partners and wanted to learn more about our program. During our discussion, I asked about their activity level, given that the economy has improved, and unemployment had reached a historic low. I was somewhat surprised to learn that their business was still strong. He said that, notwithstanding the strength of the economy, many companies are reorganizing their workforces to better serve their customers and achieve a competitive advantage. I found this interesting and made a mental note to explore the issue further as I thought it would be a good topic for an article. Two weeks ago, my health-care-consultant-friend and colleague, Faith told me that she had just finished an engagement to help a client through a major reorganization. That triggered the memory of my conversation with the Outplacement Consultant so I asked her if she would like to collaborate on a blog post. I find it interesting to learn how large companies endeavor to maintain a competitive advantage as we transition further into the Digital Age.
In my work as a Health and Wellness Consultant, I can attest that healthcare organizations can be organized in unique configurations. Each configuration requires a communication strategy that melds with their design. In my experience, the Global, Fortune Five Hundred, hierarchically structured company suffers the most challenging communications dilemma. Consider, hundreds of thousands of employees with different grade levels, or rank, associated with unique responsibilities, communicating through a pyramid structure from multiple locations and time zones. Organizations of this size and scope employ Subject Matter Experts, Medical Directors, Clinicians, and Clinical Account Executives. Many aren’t in geographic proximity to hold face to face meetings but are expected to collaborate and serve the client. To be successful, these companies must be structured to support their mission.